Water Quality softener vs filter

In the realm of shower enhancements for softer shiner hair and skin, the term 'shower filter' dominates discussions, flooding online reviews and recommendations. Yet, within this seemingly simple device lies a labyrinth of confusion.  We get countless queries from users on their hair journey, each seeking the holy grail of shower filters that effectively combat hard water. This then leads us to dissect the disparity between a water/shower filter and water/shower softeners, often leaving our users quite shocked. 
While both items promise an elevated shower experience, they address distinct water concerns. So, what sets them apart? To demystify this conundrum, let's delve into the intricate science of water quality and untangle the disparities between filters and softeners.


Before delving into the specifics, it's crucial to grasp the concept of water quality and how it affects us in the context of hair care. Water quality encompasses several key factors that determine its suitability for various uses. The pH level indicates whether water is acidic, neutral, or alkaline, affecting its taste and potential for corrosion. Contaminants, ranging from bacteria to industrial chemicals, can pose health risks and degrade water quality, necessitating regular testing and treatment. Mineral content, including calcium and magnesium, influences water hardness, impacting everything from appliance performance to the taste of drinking water. Among the factors listed, water hardness primarily affects the feel of our hair. When water is hard, it contains high levels of minerals like calcium and magnesium. These minerals can bind to the hair shaft, leaving behind residue that makes the hair feel rough, dry, and difficult to manage. Hard water can also lead to buildup on the scalp, causing irritation and contributing to issues like dandruff. So, while factors like pH level and presence of contaminants can influence overall water quality and potentially impact hair health indirectly, it's primarily water hardness that directly affects the feel and texture of hair. 


Okay, now that we understand more about water quality, let's dive into shower filters and softeners:


Shower filters are designed to remove impurities and contaminants from water, offering a more refreshing and cleansing shower experience. Typically, these filters employ activated carbon or KDF (Kinetic Degradation Fluxion) media to trap sediment, chlorine, heavy metals, and other pollutants. By purifying the water, shower filters help mitigate skin dryness, irritation, and the unpleasant odor associated with chlorine. Activated carbon, a common component in shower filters, acts as a porous sponge, adsorbing impurities and contaminants as water passes through. Here's how they can positively impact hair:


  1. Removal of Chlorine: One of the primary benefits of using a shower filter for hair is the removal of chlorine from the water. Chlorine, commonly added to municipal water supplies as a disinfectant, can strip the natural oils from the scalp and hair, leaving it dry, brittle, and prone to breakage. By eliminating chlorine from the water, shower filters help maintain the natural moisture balance of the scalp and hair, resulting in softer, more manageable hair.
  2. Reduction of Heavy Metals: Shower filters, especially those utilizing media like KDF, are effective at reducing the presence of heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and arsenic in the water. These metals, if present in high concentrations, can accumulate on the scalp and hair, leading to dullness, dryness, and potential damage. By filtering out these contaminants, shower filters contribute to healthier-looking hair with improved shine and vitality.
  3. Reduction of Scalp Irritation: For individuals with sensitive scalps or conditions such as eczema or dermatitis, exposure to chlorine and other impurities in water can exacerbate irritation and inflammation. By filtering out these irritants, shower filters can help alleviate scalp discomfort, itching, and redness, promoting a healthier scalp environment conducive to optimal hair growth and overall hair health.


Shower softening systems, on the other hand, target the mineral content in water, particularly calcium and magnesium ions responsible for water hardness. These systems employ various techniques such as ion exchange or salt-based regeneration to reduce water hardness, transforming hard water into soft, mineral-free water. Ion exchange is a common method used in shower softening systems. Resin beads within the softener attract calcium and magnesium ions, swapping them with sodium ions. This process effectively reduces the mineral content in the water, preventing the buildup of limescale and preserving the performance of your plumbing and appliances. Salt-based regeneration involves periodic flushing of the resin beads with a brine solution, restoring their ion exchange capacity.


Here's how shower softeners can improve hair:

  1. Prevention of Dryness and Brittle Hair: Hard water, characterized by high levels of calcium and magnesium ions, can leave a residue on the hair, making it feel dry, brittle, and less manageable. Shower softening systems remove these minerals from the water, preventing the buildup of mineral deposits on the hair shaft. As a result, hair becomes softer, smoother, and more hydrated, reducing the risk of breakage and split ends.
  2. Enhanced Lathering and Rinsing: Soft water allows shampoos and conditioners to lather more effectively and rinses out more completely. In hard water, the minerals react with the surfactants in hair care products, forming insoluble compounds that can leave residue on the hair, making it feel weighed down and less clean. With softened water, hair care products can work more efficiently, resulting in a thorough cleanse and leaving hair feeling lighter and fresher.
  3. Improved Color Retention: For individuals with color-treated hair, shower softeners can help preserve the vibrancy and longevity of hair color. Hard water can strip away the pigments from the hair shaft, causing color to fade more quickly. Soft water, free from mineral deposits, allows the color molecules to adhere to the hair more effectively, extending the time between color touch-ups and maintaining a vibrant, salon-worthy hue.
  4. Reduced Scalp Irritation: Hard water can be harsh on the scalp, causing irritation, itching, and flakiness, particularly for individuals with sensitive skin or scalp conditions. By removing the minerals responsible for water hardness, shower softeners create a gentler showering experience that is less likely to aggravate scalp issues. Softened water can soothe the scalp, reducing inflammation and promoting a healthier environment for hair growth.
  5. Silky Smooth Texture: Softened water leaves hair feeling silky smooth and more manageable. Without the mineral buildup that occurs with hard water, hair strands are able to glide past each other more easily, reducing tangling and making styling more effortless. The result is hair that looks and feels healthier, with increased shine and vitality.


So now you may be wondering which do I need, do I need both? It honestly depends on your hair goals/issues and your current water quality. The first step is to find out the quality of your water, you can do this by purchasing a water testing device to test the quality of your water. A good device will let you know the pH level, contaminant level, and the hardness or softness of your water. You can also contact your local water provider for more information on your water quality. If you don't have hard water then a shower filter will be enough, however, if you do you may need a water softener in addition to a shower filter. Factors like budget, space availability for installation, and personal preferences will come into play next. If concerns revolve around chlorine odor, dry skin, and irritation, a shower filter might suffice, while hard water symptoms like limescale buildup and dry, brittle hair may warrant a shower softening system.  


Ultimately, the decision to go with a shower filter, a shower softening system, or a combination of both depends on your individual water quality needs, preferences, and budget. By considering these factors and conducting thorough research, you can choose the solution that best fits your requirements and enjoy the benefits of higher quality water for your tresses.

Social Share


Elia Seyfried

Elia enjoys a good book, is a hair care enthusiast, loves to write, and hopes to inspire and educate through her work.

Recent Post